Business Insurance Sales Producer Lead

Gusto, Inc. · USA

Company

Gusto, Inc.

Location

USA

Type

Full Time

Job Description

About the Role:

Gusto is actively searching for a dynamic and inspiring commercial P&C insurance sales leader to further accelerate Gusto's growth in the business insurance space. You will be responsible for driving new revenue by cross selling Gusto’s insurance solutions to both prospects and our existing client base with a focus on Commercial Property & Casualty policies. The pace in Gusto sales is fast and the landscape we’re playing in is ever-changing. We’re looking for someone who is motivated by that and who will bring their experience creativity and passion for empowering sales professionals to the table every single day. You align with our company values and have a knack for building for the long haul. If you’re passionate about developing people shaping processes and you’re excited to roll up your sleeves and lead by example let’s talk.

About the Team:

You will initially manage one licensed P&C sales agent hired for this critical pilot with a path to leading a larger team in the near future. This team is central to evolving Gusto’s business insurance strategy and is crucial to solving customer experience gaps and optimizing our offline insurance channels. Your team will serve as Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) performing the 'human-in-the-loop' workflows required to train and optimize the AI Insurance Advisor Gus. Our collective vision is to be an expert advisor that supports small businesses through every stage of growth with this pilot and the team you lead being key to establishing our digital insurance agency and licensed agent integration.

Here’s what you’ll do day-to-day:

  • Lead a team of P&C sales advisors to achieve and exceed weekly/monthly/quarterly targets for P&C policies.

  • Encourage and empower your team to perform to their full potential. Build a world-class consultative sales team by investing in and developing the existing sales team while at the same time attracting top sales talent to Gusto.

  • Coach and support the team in their role as subject matter experts (SMEs) providing 'human-in-the-loop' support to optimize the AI Insurance Advisor Gus and assisting customers with complex P&C needs.

  • Collaborate with Sales Marketing and Product leadership to identify market opportunities drive leads and pipeline progression and help shape the product vision and strategy.

  • Use data to inform decision-making and focus areas - ranging from advisor skill development (e.g. coaching conversations email campaign usage) to team initiatives (e.g. staffing to seasonality piloting new activities). Track measure and report-out on sales effectiveness against targets and adjust programs and strategies as necessary.

  • Build a culture of fun and excellence within the team. Cultivate each individual’s skill set development and guide career pathing as they grow within the organization.

  • Ensure the team maintains compliance with all state licensing and continuing education (CE) requirements for P&C insurance.

Here’s what we're looking for:

  • P&C Insurance Expertise: 4-6 years of experience as a national producer for the small commercial P&C market

  • Management Experience: 3+ years of people management experience in a sales organization.

  • Licensing: An active Property & Casualty insurance producer’s license or the ability to obtain upon hire.

  • Results-Oriented: Consistent track record of establishing and exceeding measurable goals.

  • Sales Acumen: Experience with start-up environments and SMB SaaS sales models and excellent working knowledge of inbound and outbound SaaS sales methodologies.

  • Coaching Passion: A passion for coaching advisors on discovery objection handling and soft skills.

  • Collaboration: Ability to interact effectively with multiple teams; excellent social and interpersonal skills.

  • Education: Bachelor’s degree from an accredited university.

  • Technical Proficiency: Working knowledge of carrier quoting systems proficiency in insurance software and Salesforce.com (SFDC) experience required.

  • Comfortable using AI tools and automation to enhance productivity decision-making and problem-solving.

Our cash compensation amount for this role is $143675 to $176000 OTE for Denver Atlanta Chicago & Las Vegas. $163265 to $200000 OTE for San Francisco & New York. $126530 to $155000 OTE for Phoenix. Final offer amounts are determined by multiple factors including candidate location experience and expertise and may vary from the amounts listed above.

Apply Now

Date Posted

12/23/2025

Views

0

Back to Job Listings Add To Job List Company Profile View Company Reviews
Positive
Subjectivity Score: 0.65

Similar Jobs

Growth Product Lead - Loyalty - Trafilea

Views in the last 30 days - 0

Trafilea promotes itself as a transformative consumer tech platform with AIdriven growth solutions highlighting achievements like 1B revenue and globa...

View Details

Sales Prospecting Account Executive - Financial Solutions - Blackbaud

Views in the last 30 days - 0

This job posting seeks Prospect Account Executives to sell Financial Management applications for nonprofits and governments Responsibilities include s...

View Details

Team Lead - Publisher Success Management (AdTech) - MGID

Views in the last 30 days - 0

MGID is a fastgrowing digital advertising company seeking a resultsdriven Team Lead to oversee client relationships and drive business growth in the U...

View Details

Head of Sales - Mapbox

Views in the last 30 days - 0

The text describes Mapbox as a leading location platform with 4 million developers highlighting its tools for businesses and a sales role requiring ex...

View Details

Engineering Manager - Software Supply Chain Security: Auth Infrastructure - GitLab

Views in the last 30 days - 0

This job description highlights a leadership role in developing secure scalable authentication infrastructure for GitLab It emphasizes technical exper...

View Details

Staff Salesforce Engineer - CRM Systems - GitLab

Views in the last 30 days - 0

This job description outlines a Staff Salesforce Developer role focusing on designing building and scaling enterprisegrade solutions across Salesforce...

View Details